Quantcast
Channel: Comments on: Luck play wasn’t reversed because referee didn’t see conclusive video
Browsing all 38 articles
Browse latest View live

By: S.Nevada

Down or not, it’s still a bone-headed decision to throw the ball it in that instance.

View Article



By: logicalvoicesays

Andrew Lea…Luck is a hack all around. What an injustice and sin if RGIII doesn’t win Rookie of the year.

View Article

By: dxl115

If you think gambling didn’t have something to do with the replay assistant “not feeding the ref the right shot” you’re naive. The line moved two points in Tennessee’s favor before game time.

View Article

By: hoosiercolts

I’m not gonna bitch and moan too much over this call. Luck should have held onto the ball instead of throwing it but….. the refs really blew this call. Just glad that this boneheaded mistake from Luck...

View Article

By: truthfactory

Every camera angle that I saw showed his knee down. If this were the replacement refs it would have been all over sportscenter about how terrible of a job they were doing. This one was unexcuseable

View Article


By: joetoronto

Well that explains why the call was made but it doesn’t explain why the video wasn’t made available.

View Article

By: cooklynn17

Then this ref should be fired, because it dosent get more conclusive than that. So obvious it’s not even funny. Close yes but easy enough to make the correct call. Sort of like the Greg Jennings fumble...

View Article

By: jaxbeachjagfan

Kid’s a rookie. I give him credit for keeping his eyes (and mind) looking downfield. The guy my team drafted would’ve been curled up on the ground as soon as he heard the heavy breathing and footsteps.

View Article


By: jelliot1978

The NFL should adopt the way the NHL does their reviews. With the NHL war room you have a dedicated group watching in Toronto and can initiate a review to the on ice officials. A system like this would...

View Article


By: essentialsausage

Good thing the “real” refs are back!

View Article

By: richwizl

Luck and the Colts have been pretty “Lucky” all season, I think. Good first year for him, but the Texans will probably stomp them twice in the next few weeks.

View Article

By: bkostela

in fairness to the official, the “conclusive” replay angle wasn’t shown on the CBS broadcast until after they already reviewed the play. not to say the official didn’t have access to that angle before...

View Article

By: hehateme2

Luck got away with another “knee on the ground” throw against the Dolphins. He’s really good though.

View Article


By: chatham10

When the replacement refs were working the games the announcers could not wait to bash them for bad calls but each week I watch the same bad calls and nothing is said. I wish the NFL would provide...

View Article

By: randygnyc

So, theoretically, the network airing any NFL game, could manipulate replay angles and availability? I see no conflict there…..

View Article


By: mossnomore

Not that it Ended up making a difference overall, but no one pointed out the ref’s error in the Bucs Eagles game. With 35 seconds left in the game, the Bucs were flagged for 12 men on the field and...

View Article

By: ialwayswantedtobeabanker

The ref is now claiming he didn’t see conclusive evidence??? That’s a lame excuse — I haven’t seen an angle on that play that wasn’t conclusive. What more did the guy need? Sounds like the ref is...

View Article


By: grendelg

The video looked conclusive, but the picture in the story seems to show his knee not on the turf yet. At least it didn’t change the outcome of the game.

View Article

By: FinFan68

Was he watching the right play? How is it possible that only 1 angle showed his knee on the ground? (It was clear to me in all the angles that I have seen) This was inexcusable and another one of those...

View Article

By: xli2006

There were only 2 parts of that play: 1) Luck throwing and 2) the Return… what part of that play could they have possibly shown to the ref? The play itself was only a few seconds and there was really...

View Article
Browsing all 38 articles
Browse latest View live


Latest Images